Emmerdale fans have been left speculating after Monday night’s intense episode,
which featured the horrifying limo crash and the discovery of a mysterious body beneath the icy lake.
While Amy Wyatt (Natalie Jamieson) was trapped underwater,
viewers spotted another figure submerged in the lake, sparking countless theories about the identity of the deceased villager.
Now, fans believe they may have worked out exactly who it is—and the prime suspect behind their potential murder.
Clues Point to Nate Robinson
One of the most talked-about theories among Emmerdale fans is that the body in the lake belongs to Nate Robinson (Jurell Carter). Nate left the village last year to move to Shetland, but his sudden and unexplained departure has always raised questions. Now, with the latest clues, fans think his fate may have been much darker than previously thought.
The biggest clue? The bracelet seen on the body’s hand. Observant viewers noticed that the bracelet matched one that little Frankie, Nate’s daughter, had made for him before he left. This small but significant detail has fueled speculation that Nate never made it to Shetland and was instead murdered and dumped in the lake.
Is John Sugden Behind Nate’s Death?
If Nate’s body is truly in the lake, the next question is: who put him there? Many fans believe John Sugden (Oliver Farnworth) could be responsible.
Suspicion around John has been building for some time. He was one of the last people seen with Nate before he disappeared, and his conversation with Tracy (Amy Walsh) raised even more red flags. When Tracy questioned why Nate didn’t say goodbye to Frankie, John’s response seemed evasive, only fueling speculation that he knows more than he’s letting on.
On social media, Emmerdale viewers have been discussing the possibility that John killed Nate. One fan theorized, “Nate was in that lake, and I’m convinced it was John who put him there.” Another added, “John will turn out to be a killer if they find water in Anthony’s lungs too.”
Could Caleb Milligan Be the Culprit?
While many fans believe John is responsible, others suspect Caleb Milligan (Will Ash) might have had something to do with Nate’s death.
Caleb had a brief fling with Tracy, and their complicated history has made some viewers question whether he had a motive to harm Nate. Some fans think Caleb may have seen Nate as an obstacle or a threat, leading to a violent confrontation.
One viewer speculated, “If it was Nate under the water, who killed him? I think Caleb did.” Another agreed, saying, “I think it will come out that Caleb killed him for what went off with Tracy.”
Are There More Bodies in the Lake?
Some fans believe there could be more than one body lurking beneath the icy water. Another name that has been thrown into the mix is Anthony (Nicholas Day), Ruby Fox-Milligan’s (Beth Cordingly) father.
According to this theory, John may not have just killed Nate—he may have also been responsible for Anthony’s death. One viewer suggested, “I think Nate and Anthony are both in the lake because John put them there.”
If this turns out to be true, it would suggest that John has been covering up multiple murders, making him one of the most dangerous figures in the village.
Amy’s Close Call and the Aftermath
During Monday night’s episode, Amy was pulled from the lake, but things weren’t looking good for her survival. Meanwhile, Leyla (Roxi Shahidi) and Kerry (Laura Norton) managed to escape the limo wreckage, but Suzy Merton (Martelle Edinborough) tragically perished in the crash. As the limo sank, Suzy’s lifeless body went down with it.
As the emergency responders arrived, the villagers were rushed to the hospital, and it was confirmed that one of them did not survive. However, the identity of the deceased remains a mystery. Could it be Amy, still fighting for her life? Or has another victim been discovered beneath the ice?
What’s Next for the Mystery?
As Emmerdale continues to unravel the mystery of the limo crash and the bodies in the lake, fans are on the edge of their seats waiting for answers. If Nate’s body is found, it could blow open a shocking murder case, potentially exposing a long-hidden crime.
Whether John Sugden or Caleb Milligan—or even someone else entirely—is responsible remains to be seen. But one thing is certain: the drama in the Dales is far from over.
Who do you think is beneath the icy lake? And more importantly, who put them there? Stay tuned as the mystery unfolds.
Follow us to see more useful information, as well as to give us more motivation to update more useful information for you.
