The latest gripping storyline in Emmerdale has left fans buzzing with speculation, particularly
around the mystery of who is blackmailing Manpreet Sharma. Initially, suspicion fell on Billy Fletcher and Ella Forster — but viewers are now convinced the truth lies elsewhere. Manpreet recently confided in her colleague Ella, revealing she was being blackmailed after
joining a subscription website and sharing intimate photos. Ella encouraged her to delete
the account, hoping to end the nightmare. However, moments after deactivating it, Manpreet received a chilling text from the blackmailer. The message made it clear that deleting her profile wouldn’t stop the torment. The blackmailer even included screenshots of her account, reinforcing their hold on her by warning: “One word to the police and everyone will know your secret.” This tense exchange unfolded just before Thursday night’s episode (March 12), setting the stage for even more drama.
That same evening, viewers watched Billy, frustrated after being rejected by his wife Dawn Fletcher (played by Olivia Bromley), turn to Manpreet’s subscription site. To his dismay — and viewers’ surprise — the account had already been deactivated, leaving him unable to access the photos. This development led many fans to rule Billy out as the blackmailer. His disappointed reaction seemed genuine, contradicting the idea that he was behind the threats.
Fans quickly took to X (formerly known as Twitter) to share their thoughts. One viewer noted: “Ooh! So Billy has been lusting after Manpreet cos Dawn is not putting out! But he is not the blackmailer, cos he looked disappointed the page had been shut down.” Another added: “So is it supposed to be Billy blackmailing Manpreet… I hope not #emmerdale.” A third chimed in, “Billy is blackmailing Manpreet? Surely not.”
While Billy’s disappointment seemed to clear him, attention turned to Ella. Her supportive demeanor and shady past raised eyebrows among viewers. However, sharp-eyed fans were quick to notice a critical detail: every time Manpreet received a blackmail text, Ella was sitting right beside her. This timing made it highly unlikely that Ella could be the one sending the messages, despite her questionable background.
On Wednesday’s This Morning, soap expert Sharon Marshall added fuel to the fire. She teased that the blackmailer is indeed someone from the village, hinting that more twists and turns are on the horizon. This revelation only deepened the mystery, leaving viewers eager to uncover the truth.
Among the growing pool of suspects, Wendy Posner’s name keeps resurfacing. Wendy, played by Susan Cookson, is a former workmate of Manpreet’s who previously fled the village under a cloud of her own blackmail scandal earlier this year. Some fans believe Wendy may have returned to exact revenge or perhaps was never truly gone. One theory circulating online suggests: “I think Manpreet’s blackmailer is another victim of blackmail. I think it’s Wendy trying to get back at the surgery!” This sparked a wave of agreement, with other viewers echoing Wendy’s name as a likely culprit.
However, Wendy isn’t the only suspect drawing attention. Tracy Metcalfe, portrayed by Amy Walsh, has also emerged as a prime candidate. Recent episodes revealed Tracy’s financial struggles, and fans were quick to connect the dots. Her brief appearance during Manpreet’s lunch with Ella on Wednesday night raised suspicion, particularly because she seemed to linger just long enough to suggest she might be hiding something.
One viewer speculated: “Tracey who needs money,” while another added, “I think Tracey too. Wendy’s left now, and I doubt she would do that — it’s someone desperate for cash.” Yet another fan proposed: “Tracy. She knows about that type of work and she needs the cash.”
Theories continue to swirl, but the truth remains elusive. With the show promising more twists in the coming episodes, it’s clear this mystery is far from over. Whether it’s Wendy seeking revenge, Tracy driven by financial desperation, or an unexpected third party waiting to be revealed, fans are hooked — and Emmerdale has once again proven its ability to keep viewers on the edge of their seats.
Whoever the blackmailer turns out to be, one thing’s for certain: the fallout from this storyline is bound to be explosive. Stay tuned, because the drama is only just beginning.
Follow us to see more useful information, as well as to give us more motivation to update more useful information for you.
