Emmerdale fans believe they may have uncovered the shocking truth behind Nate
Robinson’s (played by Jurell Carter) mysterious disappearance and apparent murder. The latest theories suggest that Moira Dingle (Natalie J. Robb) may have accidentally killed her own stepson, with Mackenzie Boyd (Lawrence Robb) later disposing of the body to protect
his sister. This speculation comes after Amy Wyatt (Natalie Jamieson) made a grim
discovery, spotting Nate’s lifeless body beneath the frozen surface of a lake following the devastating limo crash.
Before her tragic passing, Amy managed to utter Nate’s name to Matty Barton (Ash Palmisciano). However, it remains unclear whether Matty truly registered what she was saying in her final moments. Meanwhile, Nate’s estranged wife, Tracy Robinson (Amy Walsh), has been left puzzled by his sudden lack of communication. She has tried multiple times to reach out to him, particularly after the limo crash that claimed three lives, but her calls have gone unanswered.
The mystery surrounding Nate’s fate has been further fueled by a series of flashforward sequences aired by ITV during the New Year’s episodes. These teasers offered cryptic glimpses into upcoming events in 2025, including an eerie image of someone struggling beneath an icy lake and another featuring Mackenzie frantically running, seemingly in fear. Now, viewers are speculating that Mack was fleeing the scene after disposing of Nate’s body—but crucially, they believe he was not the one who killed him.
Instead, fans suggest that Moira may have unknowingly been responsible for Nate’s death due to the effects of her undiagnosed brain tumour. Last year, Moira’s condition led to significant changes in her personality, including moments of intense aggression and terrifying hallucinations. These symptoms had already caused her to act erratically, and one of the most shocking incidents occurred when she attempted to rekindle her past affair with Nate in the barn. However, the illicit moment was witnessed by Caleb Miligan (William Ash), who wasted no time in informing his brother, Cain Dingle (Jeff Hordley). Enraged by what he believed to be another betrayal, Cain lashed out at Nate, beating him brutally and accusing him of trying to seduce Moira once again.
Despite Nate’s protests of innocence, he later made a hasty decision to leave Emmerdale behind, announcing a fresh start in Shetland. However, following his abrupt departure, no one has heard from him. Given the eerie flashforwards and the mysterious circumstances of his disappearance, fans now suspect that Moira may have suffered a medical episode and accidentally killed Nate during a moment of confusion or rage. If this theory holds true, Mackenzie may have discovered what had happened and, in an attempt to shield his vulnerable sister from the consequences, took matters into his own hands by hiding the body.
Emmerdale fans have taken to social media to discuss their suspicions, with many pointing towards Mack’s panicked sprint through the woods as a key clue. One viewer shared their theory on Facebook, writing: “Do you think maybe Moira killed Nate due to her brain tumour and doesn’t have a clue? Hence why you saw Mackenzie running through the woods in the flashforward episode. Maybe he witnessed it and hid Nate’s body in the lake to protect Moira. Probably wrong, but just a different theory.”
Another fan chimed in with an intriguing question: “Yeah, I like that idea, but who’s got his phone and sent Frankie the birthday present?” This comment references an unsettling detail—despite Nate’s supposed absence, someone managed to send a birthday gift to his daughter, Frankie, raising further questions about who may have access to his belongings and whether they are trying to cover up his fate.
A third fan agreed with the theory, stating, “Yes, that sounds like a really good thought,” while another speculated, “I think whoever killed Nate will ultimately get away with it.” One viewer also recalled a past incident that could connect to the theory: “That’s an interesting theory, actually. He did chase her into the woods that time when she had the seizure. Would make sense.”
As Emmerdale continues to unravel the mystery surrounding Nate Robinson’s fate, fans eagerly await further clues that may confirm or disprove their suspicions. Could Moira’s tragic medical condition have led to an unthinkable act? Did Mackenzie play a crucial role in concealing the truth? And if someone else is involved, who is ensuring that Nate’s disappearance remains a secret? One thing is certain—this storyline is keeping Emmerdale viewers on the edge of their seats, eagerly piecing together every clue in the hopes of solving the puzzle before the truth finally comes to light.
Follow us to see more useful information, as well as to give us more motivation to update more useful information for you.
