A sinister twist could be on the horizon in Emmerdale if a chilling new theory turns out to be
true. Speculation is running rampant that John Sugden may be hiding a deadly secret, with some fans believing he could be a covert murderer responsible for multiple deaths in the village. With fresh spoilers hinting that another character may soon be in grave danger, the suspense continues to build.
For months, Emmerdale viewers have been trying to piece together the mystery surrounding
the disappearance and subsequent death of Nate Robinson. Originally thought to have left the village last year, Nate’s remains were shockingly discovered submerged in the lake, sending shockwaves through the community. To this day, the identity of his killer remains unknown, but many are convinced that John Sugden is the culprit.
Adding fuel to the fire, just weeks ago, John was seen assisting in the disposal of Anthony Fox’s body after Ruby Miligan murdered him. However, a faction of fans remains unconvinced that Anthony was actually dead when John got involved. Some speculate that John may have been the one who ultimately took Anthony’s life, using Ruby’s crime as a convenient cover for his own dark intentions. If this theory proves accurate, it suggests that John may be far more dangerous than anyone realizes—and that his list of victims is only growing.
Now, it seems that another character may be on the verge of uncovering the truth, putting their own life in peril. Next week, Jai Sharma begins to grow suspicious of his boss, Caleb Miligan, unaware that Caleb, along with Ruby, John, and others, has been keeping a deadly secret. As reported by The Mirror, Jai’s concerns start to mount after an encounter with Caleb reveals that something is amiss.
Jai, who has a sharp intuition, picks up on Caleb’s unease when the topic of Anthony’s disappearance comes up in conversation. Caleb’s nervous reaction, his hesitant body language, and his reluctance to answer direct questions immediately set off alarm bells for Jai. He starts to put the pieces together, convinced that Caleb is hiding something far bigger than just a missing person case.
Determined to get to the bottom of it, Jai confronts Caleb, pressing him for answers. He starts to suspect that Anthony’s fate is tied to something much darker than anyone has admitted, and he refuses to let the matter drop. But as he digs deeper, Jai may be putting himself in grave danger.
If John really is a killer, and if he has gone to extreme lengths to cover up his previous crimes, would he hesitate to silence Jai to keep his secret safe?
The stakes are high, especially considering Jai’s history with Caleb. The two men have been at odds ever since Caleb double-crossed Jai last year, stripping him of his power and status. Jai has every reason to want to expose Caleb and take him down—especially if it means uncovering a serious crime in the process. But could his determination to seek justice end in his own downfall?
As the mystery deepens, some fans are beginning to wonder if this could signal Jai’s exit from the ITV soap. Given that he has taken a backseat in recent storylines since losing everything, this sudden involvement in a high-stakes plot could either be the start of a redemption arc—or a tragic farewell. If John is indeed a murderer, and if Nate and Anthony were only the beginning, could Jai be his next target?
Audiences have long suspected that John is hiding something sinister. When he first arrived in Emmerdale last September, he carried an air of mystery, and his past seemed deliberately vague. The biggest red flag came when it was revealed that John owned dog tags belonging to a man named Aidan Moore. John claimed that Aidan was a comrade from his army days who had tragically passed away. But skeptical fans believe there’s more to the story—that Aidan may have been murdered by John, just as Nate and Anthony might have been.
As Jai edges closer to the truth, the real question is: how far will John go to keep his secrets buried? If Jai refuses to back down, will he become the next name on John’s growing list of victims? Or will he manage to expose the village’s most dangerous secret before it’s too late?
Follow us to see more useful information, as well as to give us more motivation to update more useful information for you.
