Speculation is mounting over who could step into the lead role in Midsomer Murders should Neil Dudgeon decide to depart from the long-running ITV crime drama.
While the actor has not announced any immediate plans to leave, he recently hinted at the inevitability of being replaced in the future.
In a candid interview, Dudgeon, who portrays DCI John Barnaby, acknowledged that his tenure on the show will eventually come to an end.
Speaking to Radio Times, he shared: “I’m very happy in the countryside, it’s very nice. And no, I assume that at some point, I’ll get the hook.”
Until that day comes, however, he intends to continue portraying the much-loved detective.
Despite no confirmed departure, bookmakers have begun speculating on who might be next in line to take on the role.
Among the notable names mentioned is Coronation Street star Sue Cleaver, raising the question of whether Midsomer Murders could soon introduce its first female lead detective.
Sue Cleaver: A Strong Contender?
Sue Cleaver, widely recognized for her portrayal of Eileen Grimshaw in Coronation Street, recently announced her departure from the soap after 25 years. This has fueled rumors that she could transition into the world of crime-solving drama. With odds set at 10/1, Cleaver is among the potential replacements for Dudgeon should he decide to step away from the role.
In a recent interview, Cleaver opened up about her decision to leave Coronation Street, revealing that her exit had been in the works since 2022. While appearing on Loose Women, she stated: “I have decided after 25 wonderful years that it is time to hang Eileen back up in the prop cupboard. I’ve decided it’s time to leave, they’re keeping the door firmly open for me. It’s just the right time!”
Her departure aligns with speculation that Midsomer Murders might be looking to introduce a fresh dynamic, and her wealth of acting experience makes her a strong candidate.
Other Possible Replacements for Neil Dudgeon
While Cleaver’s name has sparked intrigue, she is not the only contender being considered for the role. Bookmakers have also suggested Vera star Kenny Doughty as the frontrunner, with odds of 5/1. Doughty, best known for his role as DS Aiden Healy in Vera, has already proven his ability to handle detective roles, making him a natural choice.
Following closely behind is Death in Paradise star Ralf Little, who has been given 6/1 odds. Little’s established reputation in crime dramas further strengthens his candidacy, and his departure from Death in Paradise could make him available for the role.
Another intriguing possibility is Kirsty Dillon, who played WPC Gail Stephens in Midsomer Murders until 2011. With 8/1 odds, her return would mark a significant moment for the show, potentially making her the first female lead detective in its history.
According to Mike Reading, a spokesperson for Betway, “With speculation swirling about Neil Dudgeon’s future in Midsomer Murders following the cancellation of spin-off McDonald & Dodds, anticipation is mounting over who could step into the role of DCI John Barnaby as the next lead detective in the beloved crime drama.”
A Major Change for Midsomer Murders?
If Sue Cleaver were to take on the lead detective role, it would mark a historic shift for the series. Since its inception, Midsomer Murders has always featured male detectives at the forefront, from John Nettles’ Tom Barnaby to Neil Dudgeon’s John Barnaby. Cleaver stepping into the role would not only offer a fresh perspective but also align with broader trends in television that embrace diversity and strong female leads.
However, other former cast members are also in the running. Daniel Casey, who played DS Gavin Troy, has odds of 9/1, suggesting that a familiar face could return to take on the detective mantle. Meanwhile, original star John Nettles remains an extreme long-shot at 80/1, though, given Midsomer Murders’ penchant for surprises, anything remains possible.
As Midsomer Murders approaches its 30th anniversary, the potential for a major shake-up grows stronger. Whether Neil Dudgeon remains in the role for years to come or the show welcomes a new lead, the speculation continues to captivate fans. For now, viewers eagerly await any official confirmation on the future of the series and its next detective.
Follow us to see more useful information, as well as to give us more motivation to update more useful information for you.
