Emmerdale fans have been left on edge after Friday night’s gripping episode, which ended with the appearance of a shadowy figure in a hooded sweatshirt.
As the dramatic scene unfolded, Tracy Metcalfe (Amy Walsh) was seen making an emotional phone call to her ex,
Nate Robinson (Jurell Carter), unaware that a mysterious figure was watching from a distance.
This latest twist has sent viewers into a frenzy of speculation, with many convinced they have identified the person lurking at the scene.
The eerie moment has also intensified existing theories about the identity of the body in the water, especially after hints that Nate may have been murdered.
Tracy’s Emotional Voicemail and the Hooded Figure
In the final moments of Friday’s episode, a devastated Tracy was seen leaving a heartfelt voicemail for Nate. Her voice trembled as she struggled to hold back tears, desperate to hear his voice despite their troubled past.
“Hi, Nate. It’s me,” she said through her sobs. “I don’t know what made me think I’d get through to you at this time, but maybe I was hoping you’d sense that I wanted to hear your voice.”
She then broke down as she continued: “Look, whatever happened with us, whatever went wrong and… just… there was a crash and Suzy, Leyla, and Amy, they all died. And I just… and I just miss you so much.”
As Tracy ended the call, the camera cut to a hooded figure standing in the shadows, silently observing the aftermath of the tragic limousine crash. With the police leaving the scene and the body in the water still not recovered, the tension reached new heights.
Is Nate the Body in the Water?
The mystery surrounding the body in the frozen lake has fueled intense speculation. Earlier in the week, Amy Wyatt (Natalie Jamieson) seemed to confirm that Nate was the one in the water before she met her untimely demise. If true, this would suggest that Nate was murdered and disposed of in the lake before the tragic crash even took place.
Several names have been thrown into the mix as potential suspects, with fans wondering who could have had a motive to kill Nate. Among those at the center of speculation are Caleb Milligan (Will Ash) and John Sugden (Oliver Farnworth), both of whom had recent interactions with Nate before his sudden disappearance.
Could Caleb Milligan Be the Hooded Figure?
One of the strongest theories emerging among fans is that Caleb Milligan is the figure in the hoodie. Suspicion grew after Caleb was seen telling Ruby (Beth Cordingly) that he had “something he needed to do” before leaving the house.
Moments later, he was spotted putting on a dark hoodie—the exact same type of clothing worn by the mysterious figure seen near the lake. This did not go unnoticed by fans, who took to social media to share their theories.
“When Caleb left on tonight’s episode, he picked up a dark-colored hoodie and put it on, and that’s what the person stood looking at the lake had on at the very end,” one viewer noted.
Another fan agreed, writing: “I think it was Caleb looking at the lake at the end.”
Many believe Caleb could be involved in Nate’s disappearance, possibly driven by jealousy or revenge over Nate’s relationship with Tracy. With Caleb’s history of scheming and his sudden urgency to leave, it’s no surprise that fans are eyeing him as the prime suspect.
Could John Sugden Be the Culprit?
Another name circulating among viewers is John Sugden, who was reportedly the last person to see Nate before he vanished. His potential involvement remains unclear, but his connection to the case has left fans wondering whether he had a role in Nate’s disappearance.
While Caleb remains the frontrunner in fan theories, John’s presence in the storyline suggests he could have played a part in whatever happened to Nate.
Did Tracy Kill Nate?
One of the most shocking theories to emerge is that Tracy herself may have been involved in Nate’s death. The idea surfaced after her emotional voicemail, which left some viewers questioning her true motives.
“So, did Tracy kill Nate?” one fan speculated, prompting another to respond, “Why did I not think of this?”
Though there has been no direct evidence pointing to Tracy, some believe her devastation could be masking guilt rather than grief. If she did have a role in Nate’s fate, it would mark one of Emmerdale’s biggest twists in recent history.
What Happens Next?
With the body in the water still unrecovered and the identity of the hooded figure unconfirmed, Emmerdale fans are eagerly waiting for answers. The show has masterfully built up suspense, leaving viewers questioning who can be trusted and what really happened to Nate.
As the investigation continues, one thing is certain: the truth will come out sooner or later. Whether Caleb, John, or even Tracy is responsible, the next few episodes promise to deliver more shocking revelations that will leave fans on the edge of their seats.
Follow us to see more useful information, as well as to give us more motivation to update more useful information for you.
