In a shocking new twist on Emmerdale, fans have been quick to piece together a mystery involving a bloodied tooth found at the scene of Anthony Fox’s death.
While many initially believed the tooth belonged to the now-deceased villain Anthony, a growing theory suggests it may actually belong to a completely unexpected character: Nate Robinson.
The recent dramatic turn of events on Emmerdale has left fans in suspense, as Anthony Fox’s violent demise is tangled with the reveal of his sordid past.
As the investigation into his death intensifies, a seemingly small detail—a lone bloodied tooth—has caught the attention of viewers, sparking wild theories about its true owner.
While some fans have assumed the tooth belongs to Anthony, others have pointed the finger at Nate Robinson,
the character who disappeared from the village in 2022 under mysterious circumstances.
Anthony Fox’s Shocking End
Anthony Fox, played by Nicholas Day, was introduced to Emmerdale in late 2023 as the estranged father of Ruby Fox-Miligan. As the storyline developed, viewers learned that Anthony had a dark past involving the sexual abuse of Ruby during her teenage years. The revelation sent shockwaves through the village, and it soon became clear that Anthony’s return to the Dales was anything but innocent.
The stakes were raised when it was discovered that Anthony was not only Ruby’s abuser but also the biological father of Ruby’s daughter, Steph. This bombshell came to light when Caleb Miligan (William Ash) found DNA test results confirming Anthony’s paternity. As tensions escalated, Caleb confronted his father-in-law, leading to a dramatic and ultimately fatal showdown in a remote barn. In a flashforward scene, Anthony’s bloodied body was discovered, and a lone tooth was found nearby.
While this seemed to suggest that Anthony had met his end at the hands of one of the many people with motives to kill him—Ruby, Caleb, Cain, or Chas—viewers couldn’t shake the feeling that there was more to the story. The discovery of the tooth hinted at a deeper mystery that Emmerdale fans were quick to unravel.
Nate Robinson: The Unexpected Theory
Despite the logical assumption that the tooth might belong to Anthony, some fans have turned their attention to a character who hasn’t been seen in quite some time: Nate Robinson. Introduced to Emmerdale in 2019, Nate quickly became involved in numerous dramatic storylines, including a romantic relationship with Rhona Goskirk and tensions with Cain Dingle (Jeff Hordley).
However, after a misunderstanding involving Moira Barton (Natalie J. Robb) and a subsequent falling out with Cain, Nate left the village in 2022. His departure was abrupt, and fans were left wondering about his fate. Over the months since his exit, there have been no significant updates on Nate’s whereabouts, fueling speculation that his story was far from over.
Now, some fans believe that Nate’s sudden absence could be linked to the missing tooth. One fan posted in a Facebook group dedicated to the show, saying, “I really think the tooth is Nate’s,” and others quickly agreed. “He left a while ago and hasn’t been heard from since,” one user pointed out, while another added, “That would be a huge twist!”
The theory suggests that Nate’s death could have been hidden from viewers, and the tooth discovered at the crime scene may be an overlooked clue pointing to his involvement. Some fans have even speculated that Nate’s killer may be the one who sent the cryptic text message to Tracy, further deepening the mystery surrounding the missing character.
The Connection to Cain Dingle
Another layer to the theory comes from the recent flashforward in which Cain Dingle was seen standing at what many assumed was Nate’s grave. Could it be that Nate never truly left the village and that his death is being covered up by those involved in the current murder mystery? If Nate was indeed the victim, his death would add another shocking twist to the ongoing Emmerdale saga.
While Emmerdale fans remain divided over whether the tooth truly belongs to Nate, the theory has gained significant traction. The potential return of Nate, or at least the revelation of his fate, would certainly send ripples through the Dales, as his connections to key characters like Cain, Moira, and Tracy would make his return—or his death—a significant plot point.
What’s Next for Emmerdale?
As the mystery surrounding Anthony’s death continues to unfold, fans are eagerly awaiting more clues and developments. Could Nate’s story be far from over? If the tooth does, in fact, belong to him, it would make for one of the most unexpected twists in recent Emmerdale history.
For now, viewers will have to wait and see how this chilling storyline plays out. With Emmerdale known for its shocking twists and suspenseful plots, the truth behind the missing tooth may just be the latest in a series of jaw-dropping revelations. Fans will no doubt continue to dissect every detail, as the mystery surrounding Anthony Fox’s death—and the identity of the tooth’s owner—unfolds in the coming weeks.
Follow us to see more useful information, as well as to give us more motivation to update more useful information for you.
